January 18, 2013

"There are some things you can't share without ending up liking each other..."

Harry Potter and the Philosopher's Stone Part II

And just like that, the first book in the Harry Potter series is done. I mean, yes, it's been two weeks since the readalong started, but still. This whole readalong is just gonna fly by, isn't it?


I'm trying to gather my thoughts and feelings and put them into a coherent post, but it's TOUGH. So much happened in such a short book! And if JKR could write about so much in just over 200 pages, then imagine the adventures that must be in store in her bigger books! My brain can't even comprehend all that's to come. Good thing I'm an adult and should be able to handle the bigger books like any ol' 12 year old reading Harry Potter.

 photo thebest_zpsde5ec11b.gif
Readalongs are the best.

So since we left off:

- JKR does a good job of making you believe that Snape is pure evil. Or at least I sure fell for it. I mean, I still don't really like him, but I am kind of glad that he's not totally out to get Harry.

-Finally! Hermione, Harry and Ron are the best of friends:

"But from that moment on, Hermione Granger became their friend. There are some things you can't share without ending up liking each other, and knocking out a twelve-foot mountain troll is one of them." (p. 132)
 photo pandas_zps036a1d07.gif
Friends forever.

-Hallelujah! Because now Hermione's nagging and bossiness is much more tolerable for some reason. I think the tone from one character towards another changes when the characters actually like each other which changes the reader's feelings towards said characters. Now that Harry and Ron are friendly with Hermione, her bossiness is just a quirk that we can all put up with. And I say this as a very bossy person myself. Because my husband tells me all the time that I'm quite bossy, yet he still loves me. So there.

-Harry finally experiences Christmas as one should and it's his "best Christmas day ever". Which is terribly sad considering that it didn't take a lot for Harry to have the best Christmas ever. A few thoughtful presents, and a great feast? God, Dursley's, how could you not have been even a little bit nice to Harry on Christmas?

 photo modernfamily_zps15c08213.gif


-The second terribly sad thing to happen in this part of the book (well, actually this part was the saddest to me, but it came after the aforementioned sad thing): Harry discovers the Mirror of Erised and sees the parents he's never even met in it. And it's all he can think about when he's not in sitting in front of the mirror. But then Dumbledore explains to Harry that the mirror "shows us nothing more or less than the deepest, most desperate desire of our hearts". And in that moment, my heart breaks for Harry. For the childhood he missed out on, the parents he never had and will never know and for all the unanswered questions he has and may never get answers to.

-We end this book with Harry coming out a hero (obviously). Harry, Ron and Hermione successfully put Fluffy to sleep, drop through the trap door and solve their way through the obstacles in order to get Harry to the Philosopher's Stone. This is where we find out that it's Quirrell who's all evil and not Snape. And Quirrell's not only evil, but he's also housing Voldemort in the back of his head. Which is disturbing, because, two heads in one. But Harry, just a young wizard, overcomes both Quirrell and Voldemort and manages to keep the Philosopher's Stone out of the wrong hands, before he passes out. When Harry comes to, Dumbledore tells him that the stone has been destroyed, but me thinks Dumbledore is *gasp* lying to Harry. We shall see.

Best quote of the second half of the book (other than the title of the this post of course):

'So light a fire!' Harry choked.
'Yes - of course - but there's no wood!' Hermione cried, wringing her hands.
'HAVE YOU GONE MAD?' Ron bellowed. 'ARE YOU A WITCH OR NOT?' (p. 202)




15 comments:

  1. Interesting theory... I've never heard anybody posit that after the first book before. We shall see!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I probably wouldn't *notice* half the things I'm noticing if I was just reading these books on my own...the readalong definitely makes me pay closer attention to details (so that I have SOMETHING to write about haha).

      Delete
  2. "And in that moment, my heart breaks for Harry. For the childhood he missed out on, the parents he never had and will never know and for all the unanswered questions he has and may never get answers to." It is SO SAD. And I know I didn't cry when I first read this book so I think I'm just heartless cos that seen is heart wrenching. Poor Harry.

    That Panda gif is great.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, my heart *broke*, but I didn't cry. I rarely cry though so heart breaking pretty much equals crying.

      Delete
  3. PANDAAAAASSS!

    I like what you said about how the tone of the characters towards each actually changes our perception of the characters. Hermiones comes off as so prissy and annoying in the beginning, but then once they're all friends it's so different - she's smart and nice enough to help them with homework and even brave enough to go do shit they're not supposed to be doing.

    Rowling has SKILLS.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And I'm SO GLAD they are friends now! I really don't know if I could put up with her otherwise. Now, already, I really like her! :)

      Rowling DOES have skills.

      Delete
  4. You're so right about the tone of the characters, although I haven't really thought about it that way before. Oh the things you learn/notice when you read this book older than the intended audience!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm a little sad that old me can't compare my thoughts with what young me thought when reading this book!

      Delete
  5. As I have been reading everyone's posts, I am reminded of just how much happens in the first book. I mean, the part at the zoo with the snake, dead unicorns, dragons, holiday celebrations, wizard shopping, and on and on. And I think of it being about the sorcerer's stone, and so I was kinda shocked at the brevity of that part.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Seriously, SO MUCH HAPPENS. It's kind of amazing that Rowling can write about a big event (like the obstacle challenge) in just several pages and you don't feel like it was too short.

      Delete
  6. Ugh, the Dursleys are the worst.

    And the mirror of Erised is pretty much the most heartbreaking part of the series (except maybe one part toward the end that I will not mention here...) and I like to imagine that Dumbledore let a whole bunch of other students besides Harry and Ron look at it. You know, just for fun.

    Like, what would Neville see? Or Hermione? Or Malfoy?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. That's an interesting question - I think Neville would see his parents. Not sure about the other 2. I wonder what McGonagall would see.

      Delete
    2. Ya, I want to know what Hermione sees too! And Hagrid!

      Delete
    3. You're totally right -- Harry and Neville probably see the same thing, which is really sad.

      And after Alice posted that link to McGonagall's backstory, I bet her Erised vision would be kind of sad, too.

      Hagrid probably sees himself as being fully accepted in the wizarding world (not having to hide his wand, etc), and maybe Hermione sees herself finally being taken seriously for all her accomplishments? Or owning a massive, beautiful library a la Beauty and the Beast?

      Have I thought about this too much? Nahhh...

      Delete
  7. Oh I hate Snape soo much. Even movie Snape hates him.

    Your comment about the mirror of Erised brought tears to my eyes. Poor Harry ;(

    ReplyDelete